BMW X3
Welcome to the ultimate BMW X3 community
122.6KVIEWS
184REPLIES
95APPRECIATES
95ACTIVE PEOPLE
03-15-2023LAST POST
08-23-2018
08-23-2018
sor user avatar
sor
Brigadier General
3,282 REP
3.1K POSTS
Have to take a look, need something before winter. Those look similar to the cheaper, taller Thule racks, part of why I'd pay for an Aeroblade is its low profile.
Appreciate0
08-23-2018
08-23-2018
XXX3 user avatar
XXX3
Second Lieutenant
United_States
160 REP
230 POSTS
Just an FYI: The OEM racks will not interfere with the sunroof operation. Thule has a warning that states that their low profile Aeroblade bars may interfere with the operation of the sunroof.

Thule warning:
Cars with sun roof: Due to the racks' low fit on the car, it may not be possible to open the sun roof when the racks are installed. Please check clearance before opening your sun roof.
Appreciate0
08-23-2018
08-23-2018
sor user avatar
sor
Brigadier General
3,282 REP
3.1K POSTS
XXX3 wrote
Just an FYI: The OEM racks will not interfere with the sunroof operation. Thule has a warning that states that their low profile Aeroblade bars may interfere with the operation of the sunroof.

Thule warning:
Cars with sun roof: Due to the racks' low fit on the car, it may not be possible to open the sun roof when the racks are installed. Please check clearance before opening your sun roof.
Yeah, I believe that's just a general warning for all cars using aeroblade. I've heard reports from X3 owners that don't seem to have a problem.
Appreciate0
08-23-2018
08-23-2018
NyRevenge user avatar
NyRevenge
New Member
United_States
8 REP
15 POSTS
I just recently added them for aesthetic purposes. I followed the spacing instructions as per the instructions on the bars. Haven't heard any noise from them up to 100.
An image attached to this post, provided by the poster
Appreciate1
08-23-2018
08-23-2018
azf100 user avatar
azf100
Private First Class
108 REP
127 POSTS
sor wrote
Yeah, I believe that's just a general warning for all cars using aeroblade. I've heard reports from X3 owners that don't seem to have a problem.
Yep, I have the Aeroblades and they work perfectly. See a few posts above for my setup.
Appreciate0
08-23-2018
08-23-2018
John Casey user avatar
John Casey
Private First Class
187 REP
195 POSTS
NyRevenge wrote
Haven't heard any noise from them up to 100.
Thanks for taking it upon yourself to test this out for the rest of us. :D
Appreciate0
08-24-2018
08-24-2018
NyRevenge user avatar
NyRevenge
New Member
United_States
8 REP
15 POSTS
John Casey wrote
NyRevenge wrote
Haven't heard any noise from them up to 100.
Thanks for taking it upon yourself to test this out for the rest of us. :D
I had to make sure the rest of you guys know before purchasing of course :D
Appreciate0
08-24-2018
08-24-2018
sor user avatar
sor
Brigadier General
3,282 REP
3.1K POSTS
For those who do get wind noise, it's highly dependent on the placement of the bars. A few inches one way or another along the rail can make a big difference.
Appreciate0
08-25-2018
08-25-2018
nlrxer user avatar
nlrxer
Registered
0 REP
1 POSTS
Thanks for the info. I've been holding out for Yakima rail mounts due to the variety of accessories (ski, bike, kayak) I have that fit the Yakima system. With the money I save on the rack system I can buy clips to fit the Yakima accessories.
Appreciate0
09-25-2018
09-25-2018
BimmerDom user avatar
BimmerDom
Second Lieutenant
Canada
43 REP
275 POSTS
I never used a roof rack system before, looking for advice.

If I use the OEM Roof Rail system # 82-71-2-414-373, can I attach 3rd party carriers or boxes on roof?

I am most interested in 2 applications:
1) Kayaks (2)
2) Ski box

BMW OEM parts tend to be expensive, looking for any options for the rail and accessories that work together for G01 2018 X3
Appreciate0
09-25-2018
09-25-2018
nogren user avatar
nogren
Captain
Sweden
340 REP
967 POSTS
Go straigt to the source, thule.com
I've got their racks and skibox. The skibox can go on most racks though. No idea about how to transport Kayaks.

/n
Appreciate0
09-25-2018
09-25-2018
BimmerDom user avatar
BimmerDom
Second Lieutenant
Canada
43 REP
275 POSTS
nogren wrote
Go straigt to the source, thule.com
I've got their racks and skibox. The skibox can go on most racks though. No idea about how to transport Kayaks.

/n
Holy crap, that's more than twice the cost of BMW OEM!
Appreciate0
09-26-2018
09-26-2018
ContactPatch user avatar
ContactPatch
Lieutenant Colonel
3,436 REP
1.9K POSTS
BimmerDom wrote
I never used a roof rack system before, looking for advice.

If I use the OEM Roof Rail system # 82-71-2-414-373, can I attach 3rd party carriers or boxes on roof?

I am most interested in 2 applications:
1) Kayaks (2)
2) Ski box

H2o saddles work perfect for kayaks.
Appreciate0
09-26-2018
09-26-2018
sor user avatar
sor
Brigadier General
3,282 REP
3.1K POSTS
ContactPatch wrote
BimmerDom wrote
I never used a roof rack system before, looking for advice.

If I use the OEM Roof Rail system # 82-71-2-414-373, can I attach 3rd party carriers or boxes on roof?

I am most interested in 2 applications:
1) Kayaks (2)
2) Ski box

H2o saddles work perfect for kayaks.
Depends on the third party accessory. When I bought my Thule ski rack it came with both attachments for their aeroblade and generic straps that can attach to any crossbar (I assume).
Appreciate0
09-26-2018
09-26-2018
nogren user avatar
nogren
Captain
Sweden
340 REP
967 POSTS
BimmerDom wrote
Holy crap, that's more than twice the cost of BMW OEM!
Thule Evo Wingbar - official list price SEK2857 (Not the cheapest option)
BMW OEM - SEK3015

Maybe perhaps I'm in Thule-country?

/n
Appreciate0
12-03-2018
12-03-2018
codex57 user avatar
codex57
Lieutenant
221 REP
485 POSTS
nogren wrote
Thule Evo Wingbar - official list price SEK2857 (Not the cheapest option)
BMW OEM - SEK3015

Maybe perhaps I'm in Thule-country?

/n
Must be. Thule and Yakima (but I think Thule is generally more expensive by a little bit) options are about twice as expensive as the OEM option. Might be even more than that with the aerobar option (I haven't checked prices in a while).

I only carry a box once every 1-2 years so going economical is more important than total ease of use. I'm thinking the OEM cross bars should work just fine with the feet that come with boxes. All the ones in the US I've seen all have these clamps that can fit a pretty wide variety of sized bars. You generally just crank them down and the clamps get tighter and tighter until they're holding onto the bars securely.
Appreciate0
12-03-2018
12-03-2018
Speedbird1 user avatar
Speedbird1
Second Lieutenant
108 REP
217 POSTS
Just wondering if anyone is aware, or has already discovered themselves, if the Thule Wingbar roofbar setup I had on my F25 LCI MSport will fit the G01 Msport roofrails? I'm hoping they will as I only got to use them once on the F25. Thanks.
Appreciate0
12-03-2018
12-03-2018
SROC3 user avatar
SROC3
The limit of adhesion is my home.
United_States
1,767 REP
3.8K POSTS
Just get a Thule Wind Deflector. Had this setup on my M4 and w/ the deflector/fairing, the noise disappeared. Plus, it looks cool too :)
https://www.amazon.com/Thule-8702-AirScreen-Fairing-44/dp/B019HK57MY/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1543871195&sr=8-2&keywords=thule+wind+fairing
Appreciate0
12-04-2018
12-04-2018
nogren user avatar
nogren
Captain
Sweden
340 REP
967 POSTS
Speedbird1 wrote
Just wondering if anyone is aware, or has already discovered themselves, if the Thule Wingbar roofbar setup I had on my F25 LCI MSport will fit the G01 Msport roofrails? I'm hoping they will as I only got to use them once on the F25. Thanks.
F25, F30/F31, and G01 got the same rails, so as long as the bar is long enough (1135mm), it should work. I'll find out tomorrow, when replacing my F31 with extra long wingbars from Thule, with a G01!
Appreciate1
12-04-2018
12-04-2018
Speedbird1 user avatar
Speedbird1
Second Lieutenant
108 REP
217 POSTS
Thanks nogren, be interesting to know if they fir. I'll also check the length of my bars.
Appreciate0
12-04-2018
12-04-2018
nogren user avatar
nogren
Captain
Sweden
340 REP
967 POSTS
Speedbird1 wrote
Thanks nogren, be interesting to know if they fir. I'll also check the length of my bars.
Forgot to mention; there is actually some details to get from thule.com .. like which ones will suit a specific car. Do the search for both cars, and compare the suggested options.

/n
Appreciate0
12-04-2018
12-04-2018
Speedbird1 user avatar
Speedbird1
Second Lieutenant
108 REP
217 POSTS
Good idea- I'll get on it.
Appreciate0