|
I've had both the prior generation X3 and current generation X1.
If your options are as presented I'd get a new X1 but make sure it has the sport seats over wrecked X3s. The new X1 will have a full new car warranty and service. When I traded my X1 in I was surprised it held its value very well.
The used X3s you are looking at are very well optioned cars. You say both have damages reported on their Carfax reports. For that reason alone I'd hard pass on these. There's so many used X3s out there I'd keep your search open if you like that model. Go test drive a new X1 and a used prior generation X3 and see what works best for you.
|