10-18-2020, 12:19 PM | #23 | |
First Lieutenant
132
Rep 362
Posts
Drives: 2016 X3 xDrive 35i
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Maryland
|
Quote:
In the past I owned a 2009 Toyota Venza. While in my opinion most Toyota's are unexciting driving appliances, I would not put most Mazdas in this category. The Mazda CX-5 is not a BMW X3 F25, but it handles and performs better than you might expect. Car & Driver in its review of the 2016 Mazda CX5 stated: "The new CX-5 isn’t the quickest CUV in the segment, but it has the poise and agility of a sports sedan. Its ride is firm but not harsh with well-controlled body motions. The Mazda’s electrically boosted steering has just-right weighting, good on-center feel, and a natural buildup of effort in turns that feels positively (old-school) BMW-like." https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews...d-test-review/ The Mazda CX-5 also came out on top of a Motor Trend comparison of nine 2016/2017 small crossovers. The review stated in part: "Out on our road loops, the Mazda offered up engaging, sporty handling with little body roll and little in the way of harshness from poor-quality roads. This one is the sports car of the bunch..." "The Mazda CX-5 with its 2.5-liter, 184-hp I-4 and six-speed automatic transmission impressed our drivers. This is the best engine here—linear power with plenty to give at both the bottom and top end. The CX-5's transmission earned praise for its quick, decisive shifts in its normal mode and for its willingness to let the four-banger sing to its redline in Sport mode." https://www.motortrend.com/cars/mazd...ison-big-test/ If the budget is limited, I would consider a newer, well-equipped and maintained Mazda CX-5 over an older BMW X3 with an uncertain driving history and perhaps a dubious maintenance record and reliability. Last edited by MichiganMike; 10-18-2020 at 07:50 PM.. |
|
Appreciate
3
|
10-19-2020, 02:32 PM | #24 | |
New Member
2
Rep 16
Posts
Drives: 2000 BMW 740iL
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: West Texas
|
Quote:
My concern was that the oil the PA inspection station saw was not from the valve cover but the vanos solenoid. So we did not change it for fear of breaking it! As it turns out, GEICO ended up giving my son enough money to buy another 2011 with 70k less miles (61k) and more options for $12,500. I had originally purchased the totaled one in Hollywood and shipped it to TX. It was a terrific vehicle! I hope my current 2011 X3 goes 150k or more! Only 45k now. |
|
Appreciate
1
Wgosma806.00 |
10-21-2020, 12:46 PM | #25 |
New Member
13
Rep 11
Posts |
OP,
We also purchased an F25 X3 due to a baby. It was a 2011 with a little over 80k miles back in February of 2017. Truth be told, I wasn't in the market for a BMW, but ended up with one by process of elimination. In a little over three years of ownership I've had to replace: 1- Starter - Died on me with no warning at work 2- Charge pipe - exploded on its own 3- High pressure fuel pump - zero warning. expensive fix 4 - LED drivers failed on BOTH taillights - common issue fixed with aftermarket drivers 5 - Oil filter housing gasket failed and was replaced 6- Random interior pieces: glovebox cover, driver's side grab handle, soft-touch material in the (pre-LCI) dashboard panels are failing or have failed While replacing the HPFP (#3) this week I noticed a blue smear on my garage floor. That's the color of BMW coolant so I suspect the water pump might be on its way out. I'll be doing an oil change and pulling the undertray to inspect this weekend. This leads to my next point. If I didn't have the tools, time, knowledge and willingness to do all of the above work myself this would be by a long shot the absolute worst car I've ever owned from a reliability and cost standpoint and it isn't even close. If I had to run to a dealer or an independent shop every time something went wrong I would've sold it long, LONG ago. That's the bad part. For comparison, we also have a 2006 Acura TL. I've spent maybe a quarter the amount I've spent on the X3 in terms of parts in 11 years of ownership. The good part: this is by far the best driving vehicle I've owned. Getting on the gas when everything is happy is a superlative experience. EDIT: commas Last edited by HalfAnP; 10-21-2020 at 12:51 PM.. |
Appreciate
1
evilchargerfan269.00 |
10-21-2020, 02:04 PM | #26 |
Lieutenant Colonel
806
Rep 1,906
Posts |
HalfAnP: water pump..I looked at good BavAuto YouTube DIY video thinking I might do my WP (PM job when I hit 100K miles), ugh even with a lift it's not a pretty job to undertake- I have N52 motor, pump is at bottom front of motor, bear to get at- your car may be similar.
It's about $1400 Indy shop R&R cost, ugh! |
Appreciate
0
|
10-21-2020, 03:53 PM | #27 | |
New Member
13
Rep 11
Posts |
Quote:
Since this was one of the common points of failure I studied the job and tried to familiarize myself before even deciding to buy the car. Even then, I'm sort of dreading it but I've done worse. If there's a bright side its that the prices of the pumps have come down a bit since I bought the car, and there appears to have been one last revision in 2019 that hopefully increases the pump's reliability. |
|
Appreciate
1
Wgosma806.00 |
10-21-2020, 04:14 PM | #29 |
Dr Drei
71
Rep 245
Posts |
OP:
Since no one has opined on the F25 with the N47 diesel option, allow me. This past January I bought a 2016 X3d with 49k miles on the clock. The only optional extras it has are adaptive LED headlamps. No Nav, sunroof, leather. It was a 1-owner lease return and would've been sold as a CPO except nobody wanted to pay the $25k dealer asking price. It eventually went to a small used car dealer where I found it and paid $19k out-the-door. The diesel was a "must have" for me, as I was commuting 200 miles daily pre-COVID, in a highly uncomfortable and anemic '14 Jetta TDI. The X3 came with new brakes all around, original RFTs which I just recently ditched in favor of regular tyres (Kumho Ecsta PA51 ftw!). Other than 1 oil change, new air and fuel filters, it has not needed anything else. It returns an average of 34-36 MPGs, rides beautifully on decent rubber and has plenty of room in the rear even for 2 grown adults. I searched nearly 3 months before I found a diesel-powered X3, they are extremely rare. At the risk of heresy on these boards, you might also want to consider a 2012-2015 MB GLK. Living in Chicago the past several winters before moving to Wisconsin, I can assure you that you'll want one of the 4Matic options selling for $13-15K. Ours is also a Bluetec and hasn't given me any grief in the 3+ years we've owned it. I do all the maintenance on our little diesel fleet and so far, both are running strong. The Bluetec has 122K miles on it, the X3d has 62K. Just another couple data points for your consideration. Good luck with your search.
__________________
GLK 250 // 126xxx miles // 36 MPG // Mobil1 ESP 5w30
|
Appreciate
1
evilchargerfan269.00 |
10-21-2020, 04:34 PM | #30 | |||
Private
62
Rep 95
Posts |
Quote:
Quote:
Thanks for sharing Quote:
This will be my third winter in Chicago and I used to live in Sweden before which had waaay more snow. I've never had AWD and I don't understand why people keep insisting on it. All that's needed are good tires. Never got stuck with my FWD Volvo or my RWD BMW. I actually kinda like the GLK but my wife hates it for some reason. The ML is really cool too but it's HUGE. (Well there was one time lol ) |
|||
Appreciate
0
|
10-21-2020, 04:46 PM | #31 |
Lieutenant Colonel
806
Rep 1,906
Posts |
My sense is that large proportion of Americans still think of diesel engines as noisy, loud and producing tons of smelly smoke in spite of that fact that that has not been the case for many many years. And if I recall correctly, there were, many many years a while back in the States, when diesel fuel's cost was $1.00/gallon or even bit more costly than gasoline.
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-21-2020, 04:55 PM | #32 | |
New Member
13
Rep 11
Posts |
Quote:
I bought this specific F25 because it had impeccable maintenance records. It'd been dealership maintained its entire life up to that point. Also, it was fully loaded save for the adaptive suspension and it was a screaming deal. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-21-2020, 09:16 PM | #33 |
Private
62
Rep 95
Posts |
Ok well, honestly it’s a bit much but it’s not crazy bad for a 9 year old car with 134000 miles that’s been driven from 80k and during 3 years.
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-22-2020, 04:26 PM | #34 | |
Dr Drei
71
Rep 245
Posts |
Quote:
Speaking of AWD, it may not be absolutely necessary but it does help. Agreed that if you live in the snow belt, it's in your best interest to have snow tires or at least excellent all-season tires. Have yet to get stuck myself. Yeah, the GLK is kind of love-it-or-hate-it styling, and my wife loves it We tried the ML250 Bluetec but it was a little too large for us as well. It does ride very nicely though.
__________________
GLK 250 // 126xxx miles // 36 MPG // Mobil1 ESP 5w30
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-22-2020, 04:51 PM | #35 | |
Colonel
880
Rep 2,547
Posts
Drives: Z4MC-X3-35i-525i, Corrado G60
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: MD
|
Quote:
I've done my fair share of driving in snow and when there are only mild hills, 2WD, especially with winter tires, can do pretty well, but once the hills get steeper, the AWD really shines and leaves the 2WD behind. Also many parts of the US don't get snow often enough to justify a set of winter tires so running AWD with all seasons will get you through most conditions. And if you've ever gotten stuck in an ice storm, you'll really wish you had AWD. Is AWD a necessity? no, but it does have its advantages in certain situations. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-22-2020, 05:48 PM | #36 | |
First Lieutenant
132
Rep 362
Posts
Drives: 2016 X3 xDrive 35i
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Maryland
|
Quote:
However, if trunk space is the concern, it appears a used CX5 will provide comparable trunk space to the F25 X3. A search directed to the 2016 CX-5 indicates it has has cargo space of 34 cubic feet with the back seat up and 65 cubic feet with the back seat down. The re-design in 2017 modified the CX-5 cargo space specs to 30.9 cubic feet back seat up and 59.6 when it is down. A similar search for the 2016 BMW X3 reveals a cargo space of 27.6 cubic feet with the second seat up and 63.3 cubic feet with the seat down. The F25 X3 is about 5 inches longer than the CX5 as well as an inch or two wider. However, because of the longer engine compartment in the X3, the CX5 actually has more leg room in both the front and rear seats. There is less shoulder and hip room in the CX5 both front and rear and perhaps an inch less head room in the front seats. Last edited by MichiganMike; 10-27-2020 at 07:55 AM.. |
|
Appreciate
0
|
10-26-2020, 08:58 AM | #37 | |||
Private
62
Rep 95
Posts |
Quote:
Quote:
I appreciate the advice but we're more likely to buy a bigger sedan than a asian or american SUV or CUV. Quote:
My wife hates the GLK for some reason lol but really likes the ML. It seems to be reliable but it's even pricier than the X3 and I don't want to know what tires and brakes cost to replace. |
|||
Appreciate
0
|
10-30-2020, 05:31 PM | #38 |
Private
17
Rep 80
Posts |
stay away from early N20. N55 is better in all respects expect maybe a bit of fuel consumption. X3 F25 is very reliable and Consumer Choice top pick. OEM parts are expensive but use aftermarket where available. Water pumps has to be replaced every 60k-80k and expensive. If not handy find a good local mechanic who knows BMWs. Never go to the stealer unless nobody else can help you. Good luck.
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-02-2020, 10:47 AM | #39 | |
Private
62
Rep 95
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-02-2020, 12:49 PM | #40 | |
Lieutenant
269
Rep 595
Posts
Drives: 2012 F25 (N55), 2014 I01 (REX)
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: San Diego / Menifee
|
Quote:
heh, my thoughts exactly! sure, a little more spent on maint / repairs, but the vehicle price point is so low (disclaimer, I was a huge lexus and toyota fan boy) |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-05-2020, 04:45 AM | #41 |
Private
62
Rep 95
Posts |
Alright, everybody. Some good news, my Volvo has been sold and will be gone by the end of next week most likely and the replacement will be bought asap when it has left my possession. I've also been able to get a 35% raise which significantly helps!
Now, I'm not going to go crazy but it allows some more flexibility and I just want to show you a couple of cars that may or may not be available in a week or two but just to show you where my mind is so I can get your thoughts. 2011 xDrive35i https://www.cars.com/vehicledetail/d...4686/overview/ Pros - Correct color combination, xenon, nice wheels, 35i engine, low miles at 59k, has all the equipment we need, it's local Cons - It's rather expensive for a 2011? Not sure if miles > age but would be nice to get it under $15k. Also at a dealership so the sales tax is 9.5% (used car from private seller would be something like $85 in comparison) 2011 xDrive35i https://www.cars.com/vehicledetail/d...0211/overview/ Pros - Great color combination (wife prefers white but honestly it does not matter), xenon, nice wheels, 35i engine, low miles at 53k, it's local.. (Pretty much the same as above) Cons - Again, same as the car above. No backup camera though? Honestly not the end of the world but resale value might hurt in the future.. A little pricey. Maybe I can pit these dealerships against eachother. 2011 xDrive28i https://www.facebook.com/marketplace...40502920288121 Pros - Good color combination, xenon, nice wheels, 28i engine, looks super clean for the miles, private seller and somewhat local. This would probably be around $5-6000 cheaper than the cars above. Cons - 28i engine I guess you could say, but honestly living in downtown Chicago I don't really care about the power, the miles are high at 110k but if I can get it cheap I don't mind a repair here or there. 2011 xDrive28i https://www.facebook.com/marketplace...42220695906929 Pros - OK color combination, xenon, 28i engine, cheap, low miles, well equipped Cons - A bit of a drive but that's fine, looks OK but has some moisture in the roof? Also the wheels are super ugly, I know they can be replaced but it's added cost and effort. What are your opinions? Obviously buying a cheaper car is always nicer but I don't want to be left disappointed. The perfect car would be newer of course but finding it difficult to find anything and I'm fine with travelling. Input is appreciated! |
Appreciate
0
|
11-05-2020, 07:45 AM | #42 | |
Private
31
Rep 75
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-05-2020, 08:23 AM | #43 | |
Private
62
Rep 95
Posts |
Quote:
Is the sport seat more important than other equipment such as backup camera from a resale pov? |
|
Appreciate
0
|
11-05-2020, 08:48 AM | #44 | |
Captain
169
Rep 660
Posts |
Quote:
|
|
Appreciate
0
|
Post Reply |
Bookmarks |
|
|