View Single Post
      06-18-2011, 06:12 PM   #32
X3andZ4owner
Private First Class
34
Rep
182
Posts

Drives: X3 Z4 630iC
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: @

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lotus7 View Post
Every real problem I've had with my X3 (and I've had some serious problems) was a result of poor quality control of German made component assemblies imported to the US for installation; none were due to the assembly of the vehicle.

BTW, the latest npr news releases have been bemoaning the fact that many “German” auto production lines are now staffed by up to 50% non-German “foreign” workers. So much for superior "German" production line skill.

Also, you may have heard that Norway's "THINK" electric car company (Aurskog, Norway) (if it survives) is planning on producing its car in the US, not Norway. Hopefully they will bring in a top notch Norwegian caulk line inspector.

As far as skin-deep quality, I totally agree and submit that BMW is putting its Euros into the places you don't see like engine internal components (where it really matters) instead of caulk line cosmetics, which from an engineering point of view are irrelevant as long as the seam is well sealed.

I'm not defending BMW as a company, only pointing out the realities of any mass-produced product. In today's global economy it's up to the consumer to do his/her homework. If caulk line cosmetics are important to you, that's perfectly fine, but if so, you should inspect the caulk lines on the demo before ordering a vehicle that does not meet your expectations.

Each of us has and is entitled to his/her own priorities. I'd rather see BMW build 3 liter engines that make 306 (European) HP and improve fuel economy 13% over their last generation of engines. You may prefer that they hire unemployed Art Majors to man the caulking guns. So be it.

I may be considered a pessimist, but IMHO to expect perfection (in every detail) today in any mass-produced product is simply being naive. However, after due consideration of all of the arguments presented here, I've moved "caulk line smoothness" from #927 to # 920 on my priority list.

P.S. I'm truly sorry that your government essentially doubles the price of a new BMW. We are fortunate that in the US our taxation has not reached these extremes, but we are headed that way.


Your right in some things.But these seam things on the picture are very visible, I did not notice them on other cars, this was the first thing I saw when I opened the trunk.. They are unsymmetrical and uneven , a poor work basically..

As for the manufacturing country quality, there are differences in production quality depending where the products are manufactured. Quality control cant sort out all of the bad apples and I thinks as for what I have heard and experienced that there are more bad apples in the US production then in the German production..

As for Think-car disaster car is only a decoy for the Norwegian government so they can say the finance nonpoluting car manufacturing.. the car is a joke, they don't even dare to crash test it because they believe it will come out as a disaster..
Appreciate 0