[bmkman]

I have a 2012 X3 and 25,000 kms. This roof rattling and noise problem has been ongoing. They keep "applying tape" ... no resolution. I think it works for a bit but when it gets cold ( below 0 ) then the sound comes back.

I have been to BMW service 5 times in the past 3 years...no resolution. They keep telling me "Felt Tape is applied"

...to add insult to injury I hate the car because it rattles so I don't really drive it so now I get slapped with a $1300 service bill to fix the brakes ( pads and rotors ) because they are rusty. I think I need to complain to BMW Canada.
I dont know if its my dealership since its my first BMW. I have owned other luxury sports vehicles before my BMW but never really had this kind of poor service....or maybe the car is just poorly designed.