Nice to see that there is a such a strong consensus among the forum members.
Since you're undecided, as is apparent from your post, you are in that rare situation of possibly racking up some brownie points with your spouse, girlfriend, boyfriend or significant other. Just let her/him decide and tell her/him that you have such faith and trust in her/his judgment that it's entirely in her/his hands.
It's a win/win situation: The decision is off your back, you get some points and if the look really sucks, you can blame it on the other person.